I’ll Never Get Rid of My Classroom Library

Recently, I was shocked to read an article written by a middle school teacher listing reasons why she was getting rid of her classroom library. I can’t imagine my fourth grade classroom without our library! This space is sacred. It’s the heart and soul of our classroom, and I will defend its presence until the end of my days. 

It’s Better to Lose a Book Than Lose a Reader*

Do I end the school year with all of my classroom library books intact? Absolutely not. Inevitably, some will get lost or forgotten at home. But others–and this is important–will be read so many times that the pages will fall out, the covers will disintegrate, and the book has to be retired. In my view, that’s the sign of a successful school year. I will never complain about replacing some of my more popular books and series each school year, because I know the reason I’m replacing them is that my students literally read them to pieces. 

Also, if you establish a procedure for your students to check out and return your library books, you will have a general sense of where you books are. And at the end of the day, it’s better for a book to be in a kid’s backpack, locker, or bedroom than sitting on a dusty shelf, never allowed to be read or loved. 

Classroom Libraries Give Kids Options 

I don’t expect my students to enter my classroom knowing how to choose a book that’s right for them. I know that I will have to model this explicitly, provide my students with strategies, allow them to practice choosing their own books, and follow up with students who are struggling to master this vital reading skill. But having a large classroom library with a wide variety of books makes this easier, not harder. 

Because I have hundreds of books across genres and reading levels in my classroom, it’s easy for me to help students learn how to choose their own book. My students don’t have to rely on leveled bins or colored stickers on a once-weekly trip to the school library in order to find a book that works for them. Using the 5-Finger Rule, they learn how to select a book that interests them and monitor their own comprehension to determine if it’s a good fit for them. And because they will have practiced choosing books in an authentic way, students are better equipped to pick their own books at public libraries and bookstores. 

Classroom Libraries are the Best Way to Encourage Real Reading

Every single day, my students walk in the classroom and immediately start reading. Some of them curl up with a pillow on the rug. Others create a little reading cave under the small group table. Still others keep it simple and stay at their desks. But they have one thing in common. They are all reading, and completely engaged in, a book from our robust classroom library. 

We don’t start off like this on day one. I have to explicitly teach and model “fake” reading versus “real” reading. We practice building our independent reading stamina every day until we reach our goal of 20 minutes daily. But there is no question that our independent reading time would not be nearly as successful or as effective if we didn’t have a large classroom library. Having a well-stocked library means that when a student finishes the second Amulet book halfway through our reading time, he can grab the third one and keep reading without losing any momentum. I’ve also discovered that many reluctant readers just haven’t found the right book, or series, or author that makes them see reading differently. Having options to choose from, time to explore those options, and opportunities to read the book they chose makes a huge impact on a student’s reading life. 

In conclusion, I’ll never, ever, ever get rid of my classroom library. I’ve seen it improve my students’ academic performance, increase how much my students read, and most importantly, turn my students into real readers. 

*Original phrase from Donalyn Miller

One thought on “I’ll Never Get Rid of My Classroom Library

  1. I am a huge advocate for keeping and growing a classroom library. Although I feel the struggles that the other article expresses, there are many apps and sign in/out initiatives that can help take away some of the novels never being returned. I struggle a lot with the fake readers who grab a book and plop down only to stare or start dozing off. However, I agree with Barnes as most just have not had the chance to have a book that does something for them offered to them. We studied a lot about this notion this summer through critical theories that really hone in on the plan to start 10-15 minutes everyday with independent reading to build stamina. I also think it is important to offer incentives to get struggling readers started. In order to maintain a well established classroom library that promotes real reading, you have to know your students and find ways to meet them at a point that will get them reading and strike their interest. However, I am not sure if independent reading or book circles work better in the classroom. Does anyone do both?

    – Taylor Brown


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s